Avant, Deborah: The market of
force, The consequences of privatising security,
Cambridge University Press, 2005, 320 p., ISBN: 0-521615356
'Deborah Avant has written a sensible corrective to the
hype and hyperbole that has accompanied the study of
'mercenaries'. She shows how private military companies are
a part of the everyday workings of national military
establishments, and provides prescient warnings about the
impact of excessive outsourcing in this area. Avant provides
an alarming message that over-reliance on private forces
undermines the spirit and commitment that make effective
national militaries work. In doing so, Avant shows how a
public ethic is an integral part of what makes national
militaries successful and how this is missing in private
military companies.' William S. Reno, Northwestern
University 'Professor Avant gives us a comprehensive,
balanced, yet ultimately disturbing look at the growing use
of private security companies. Her cases cover the gamut of
private security services and the widely varied
circumstances of their use, while her theoretical framework
links overarching trends to major concerns like military
effectiveness, professional standards, and the control of
force in the international system. Although she sees the
good as well as the worrisome in the ever-widening use of
such companies, overall her analysis raises serious
questions about the wisdom of allowing market forces, as
opposed to states and multi-national institutions, to shape
the use and professional conduct of forces around the
world.' Thomas L. McNaugher, Vice President for Army
Studies, RAND Corporation 'Avant has performed a great
service. There is much hype and hyperbole regarding the
growth of private security forces, with many suggesting that
these are warriors running wild. By sifting through the
evidence and deploying a range of organizational theories,
Avant generates develops a nuanced understanding of this
sector, identifying how these forces are controlled and
alerting us to when and where there remain legitimate
concerns. Avant tackles the interesting development of the
privatization of security. Over the last several decades
privatization has moved into the security theater with
substantial force. This is fascinating for theoretical,
political, and normative reasons. The monopolization of the
means of violence is a defining feature of the state and
distinguishes the modern sovereign state from organizational
rivals. Yet we find that states are knowingly and gladly
devolving control. Why they should do this, and with what
consequences, is important and fascinating. Avant wants to
examine the consequences by examining the impact on state
control. Toward that end, she unpacks the functional areas
in which security is being privatized and considers
different areas of state control. To illustrate these
claims, she examines three cases of state privatization and
non-state actors hiring private security forces to provide
different functions. The implications of these developments
for how politics is now being played out, who controls the
means of force, and democratic accountability, are
tremendous.' Review : Amazon / Michael N. Barnett,
University of Minnesota.
Fainaru, Steve: Big Boys Rules,
Da Capo Press, 2009, 288 p., ISBN: 0306818388
'For this mordant dispatch from one of the
Iraq War's seamiest sides, Pulitzer Prize–winning
Washington Post correspondent Fainaru embedded with some
of the thousands of private security contractors who
chauffeur officials, escort convoys and add their own touch
of mayhem to the conflict. Exempt from Iraqi law and
oversight by the U.S. government, which doesn't even record
their casualties, the mercenaries, Fainaru writes, play by
Big Boy Rules—which often means no rules at all as they
barrel down highways in the wrong direction, firing on any
vehicle in their path. (His report on the Blackwater
company, infamous for killing Iraqi civilians and getting
away with it, is meticulous and chilling.) Fainaru's
depiction of the mercenaries' crassness and callousness is
unsparing, but he sympathizes with these often
inexperienced, badly equipped hired guns struggling to cope
with a dirty war. Nor is he immune to the romance of the
soldier of fortune, especially in his somewhat pathetic
portrait of Jon Coté, Iraq War veteran and lost soul who
joined the fly-by-night Crescent Security Group and was
kidnapped by insurgents. Fainaru's vivid reportage makes the
mercenary's dubious motives and chaotic methods a microcosm
of a misbegotten war.' Review : Publishers Weekly
(Copyrights: Reed Business Information).
Fora.TV
Steve Fainaru about Blackwater
(2008)
Drohan, Madelaine: How and
why corporations used armed force to do business,
The Lyons Press, 2004, 384 p., ISBN: 1592285775
Resource control is the core of Madelaine Drohan's book.
Where the image of empire was once faceless armies,
religious zealots or expanding trade, modern conditions have
changed this view. Instead of governments launching empires,
suit-clad businessmen now decide where the action lies.
Decisions to exploit resource areas are not made in ministry
offices, but in corporate boardrooms. Businessmen, "and they
are almost always men", choose locations, make investments,
recruit workers and begin operations. Until there is unrest.
Then they call in governments to support their enterprise.
If governments cannot or will not respond, the
entrepreneur's answer is the "private army". Mercenary
professional military men act as "security" teams, policemen
or replacement armies. And they are accountable to no-one
but the firm that has hired them. Drohan's account begins
with the rule of Cecil Rhodes "who stands head and shoulders
above" the ranks of those applying military solutions to
"corporate problems". Rhodes built an immense resource
empire in Southern Africa. He also set the standard for
controlling workers as firmly as he did markets. By the
expedient of raising a battalion of "pioneers" to deal with
reluctant African peoples and recalcitrant workers, Rhodes
expanded his holdings to an unprecedented degree.
Attributing his goals to the furtherance of the British
Empire, he also ensured the continuation of profits to his
own pocket. Belgium's king Leopold followed Rhodes' example
by keeping the Congo as a personal fief. The Belgian
government was simply shunted aside on imperial affairs for
decades. The rape of the Congo is a glaring example of
imperialism run rampant, yet it set the stage for what
followed. Drohan's narrative is dominated by personalities.
Like a gaggle of rapacious ravens, men prominent in resource
enterprise descended on Africa after Rhodes. Some of these
were British, some Canadian, but others arose from among
Africa's own peoples. These last were flexing political and
economic muscle as former colonies became independent. These
new nations, with their artificial boundaries laid down
irrespective of tribal or ethnic limits, became caught up in
internal regional disputes. Resource firms played off these
rivalries to their advantage where possible. If contests for
power became too heated, the companies had the option to
withdraw or find ways of protecting their investments.
Protection was provided by "security forces" available for
hire. Among the most notorious of these was the South
African firm, Executive Outcomes. Staffed by disaffected
South African soldiers, it offered services directly or
through hidden subsidiaries. Executive Outcomes emerges
frequently, if often vaguely, as Drohan valiantly tries to
unravel the machinations the firm and its customers
perpetrated as gold, diamonds and other resources were
sought and exploited. Legality is an elusive term in these
activities. These are not distant and unrelated events. We
tend to cling to the image of investment benefiting all -
the theme of "globalisation". Drohan demonstrates how firms,
pursuing resource wealth in Africa, have followed the Rhodes
formula for success. Whether hiring private armies or simply
requesting local government forces to act in their
interests, resource firms are steadfastly ignoring the
impact on local people and their economy. Of all Drohan's
examples, the most glaring is the Talisman Energy story. Her
chapter on this operation is at once the worst and the best
example in the book. Talisman, a latecomer to Africa, seems
to have learned nothing from previous resource history in
the region. As Drohan describes it, Jim Buckee, Talisman's
head, followed a sinuous path trying to keep his firm active
in the resource field. With one eye open to profits and the
other closed to government activities done in the name of
"security" for his operations, Buckee brought his firm close
to disaster. On the other hand, the case demonstrated the
power of the public in bringing such firms to judgment.
Various large stockholders, chastened at the thought of
supporting a firm blind to the impact of its operations,
withdrew investment. It's a fine example of what individuals
can achieve in acting collectively. Drohan's book is a much
needed exposure of business morals left unscrutinised. In
her final chapter, "Perfectly Legal, Perfectly Immoral", she
shows the path to justice for people under oppressive
regimes shored up by rapacious businesses is long and
difficult. Yet, if readers pay attention, she shows how they
can be effective in making change. (...). Review : Amazon
/ Stephen A. Haines, Ottawa, Canada.
Offers an examination of the role that private security
and military contractors have played in Iraq since the fall
of Saddam Hussein. From their limited use in China during
World War II, for example, to their often clandestine use in
Vietnam ferrying supplies before the war escalated in 1964
and 1965 when their role became more prominent,
public-private military contractors (PMC's) have made
essential contributions to the success and failures of the
military and United States. Today, with an emphasis on force
restructuring mandated by the Pentagon, the role of PMC's,
and their impact on policy-making decisions is at an all
time peak. This work analyzes that impact, focusing
specifically on PMC's in Iraq since the fall of Saddam
Hussein in 2003. The author dissects their responsibilities,
the friction that exists between contractors and military
commanders, problems of protocol and accountability, as well
as the problems of regulation and control that PMC companies
create for domestic politics. The author organizes his work
thematically, addressing all facets of PMC's in the current
conflict from identifying who the most influential companies
are and how they got to that point, to the issues that the
government, military, and contractors themselves face when
they take the field. He also analyzes the problem of
command, control, and accountability. It is no secret that
PMC's have been the source of consternation and grief to
American military commanders in the field. As they work to
establish more routine protocols in the field, however,
questions are also being raised about the role of the
contractors here at home. The domestic political arena is
perhaps the most crucial battleground on which the
contractors must have success. After all, they make their
corporate living from taxpayer dollars, and as such, calls
for regulation have resonated throughout Washington, D.C.,
growing louder as the profile of PMC's increases during the
current conflict. Review : Amazon.
Al Jazeera
"Companies Frauding and Overcharging"
Interview with David Isenberg
(2011)
"David Isenberg about the
factors eading to Private Military growth in the 1990s"
In "Force Provision" by Allie Tyler
(2007)
"David Isenberg about the
categories of Private Military Companies"
In "Force Provision" by Allie Tyler
(2007)
Recent investigation into the activities of Sandline
International in Sierra Leone has rekindled interest in the
role of private armies in African conflicts. Sensational
references in newspaper articles, however, run the risk of
emphasizing the military aspect of security at the expense
of a holistic approach to an emergent security
conundrum.This fascinating book is a critique of mercenary
involvement in post-Cold War African conflicts. It seeks to
achieve a greater understanding of the mercenary-instability
complex by examining the links between the rise in internal
conflicts and the proliferation of mercenary activities in
the 1990s. The distinction in the methods adopted by Cold
War mercenaries and their contemporary counterparts, the
convoluted network between private armies, business
interests, sustained poverty in Africa's poorest countries
as well as the connection between mercenary activities and
arms proliferation. In exploring solutions to the upsurge of
mercenaries on the continent, the book seeks a political and
legal redefinition of the term "mercenaries," and calls for
new international legislation.The book argues that unless
there are complete solutions to the root causes of conflict
in a region where poverty represents the greatest threat to
democracy and development, legislation will provide only
temporary, rather than permanent, mechanisms for stemming
this disturbing trend. Review : Amazon.
Prince, Erik: Civilian Warriors, The true story of
Blackwater and the Unsung Heroes of the War on Terror, First Edition, 2013, 416 p., ISBN: 1591847214
'Forget everything you think you know about
Blackwater. And get ready for a thrilling, true story that
will make you rethink who the good guys and bad guys
have been since 9/11. No company in our time has been as
mysterious or as controversial as Blackwater. Founded by
former Navy SEAL Erik Prince in 1997, it recruited special
forces veterans and others with the skills and courage to
take on the riskiest security jobs in the world. As its
reputation grew, government demand for its services
escalated, and Blackwater’s men eventually completed nearly
one hundred thousand missions in Iraq and Afghanistan. Both
the Bush and Obama administrations found the company
indispensible. It sounds like a classic startup success
story, except for one problem: Blackwater has been demonized
around the world. From uninformed news coverage to grossly
distorted fictional portrayals, Blackwater employees have
been smeared as mercenaries, profiteers, jackbooted thugs,
and worse. Because of the secrecy requirements of
Blackwater’s contracts with the Pentagon, the State
Department, and the CIA, Prince was unable to speak out when
his company’s opponents spread false information. But now
he’s able to tell the full and often shocking story of
Blackwater’s rise and fall. In Civilian Warriors,
Prince pulls no punches and spares no details. He explains
his original goal of building an elite center for military
and law enforcement training. He recounts how the company
shifted gears after 9/11. He honors our troops while
challenging the Pentagon’s top leadership. And he reveals
why highly efficient private military contractors have been
essential to running our armed forces, since long before
Blackwater came along. Above all, Prince debunks myths about
Blackwater that spread while he was forced to remain
silent—myths that tarnished the memory of men who gave their
lives for their country but never got the recognition they
deserved. He reveals new information about some of the
biggest controversies of the War on Terror, including: The
true story of the Nisour Square massacre in Baghdad; The
actual details of Blackwater’s so-called impunity in Iraq;
The events leading up to the televised deaths of Blackwater
contractors in Fallujah. Prince doesn’t pretend to be
perfect, and he doesn’t hide the sometimes painful details
of his private life. But he has done a great public service
by setting the record straight. His book reads like a
thriller but is too improbable to be fiction.' Review :
Editor/Amazon.
Newsmax TV
Erik Prince about his Book "Civilian Warriors"
(2013)
ABC News
Blackwater Founder Fights for Reputation
(2013)
The most terrifying thing about this chronicle of a
failed coup attempt in Equatorial Guinea is that it's not a
Graham Greene novel but a true story. Roberts, an
Economist staffer, chronicles the plot by foreign
mercenaries and merchants to topple the country's brutal
dictatorship solely for the "wonga" (British slang for
"money, usually a lot of it"). An irresistibly lurid tale is
peopled with bellicose profiteers, particularly of the
neocolonialist sort from Europe and South Africa, with long
histories of investment in oil, diamonds and war-for-profit.
Among these self-styled gentleman adventurers are Margaret
Thatcher's son, Sir Mark Thatcher, and "rag-and-bone
intelligence men" who linger in hotel bars, "picking up
scraps of information... selling them on to willing buyers,
whether corporate or government." The audacity of the coup's
planners is almost admirable, though Roberts rightly
chastises them for their oil-soaked greed. As he lifts the
curtain to the backrooms of power in postcolonial Africa,
the reader finds that not much has changed on the continent
since 1618, when the "Company of Adventurers of London
Trading to the Ports of Africa" became the first private
company to colonize Africa for profit. Starred Review.
Amazon / Reed Business Information, a division of Reed
Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
PBS
Once Upon a Coup
(2009)
Al Jazeera
Simon Mann talks about Equitorial Guinea coup
(2011)
Scahill, Jeremy: Blackwater, The rise of the world's
most powerful mercenary army, B&T, 2007, 404 p.,
ISBN-10: 1560259795
Meet Blackwater USA, the powerful private army that the
U. S. government has quietly hired to operate in
international war zones and on American soil. With its own
military base, a fleet of twenty aircraft, and
twenty-thousand troops at the ready, Blackwater is the elite
Praetorian Guard for the "global war on terror"-- yet most
people have never heard of it. It was the moment the war
turned: On March 31, 2004, four Americans were ambushed and
burned near their jeeps by an angry mob in the Sunni
stronghold of Falluja. Their charred corpses were hung from
a bridge over the Euphrates River. The ensuing slaughter by
U. S. troops would fuel the fierce Iraqi resistance that
haunts occupation forces to this day. But these men were
neither American military nor civilians. They were highly
trained private soldiers sent to Iraq by a secretive
mercenary company based in the wilderness of North Carolina.
Blackwater: The Rise of the World's Most Powerful Mercenary
Army is the unauthorized story of the epic rise of one of
the most powerful and secretive forces to emerge from the U.
S. military-industrial complex, hailed by the Bush
administration as a revolution in military affairs, but
considered by others as a dire threat to American democracy.
Scahill, a regular contributor to the Nation, offers
a hard-left perspective on Blackwater USA, the
self-described private military contractor and security
firm. It owes its existence, he shows, to the post–Cold War
drawdown of U.S. armed forces, its prosperity to the
post-9/11 overextension of those forces and its notoriety to
a growing reputation as a mercenary outfit, willing to break
the constraints on military systems responsible to state
authority. Scahill describes Blackwater's expansion, from an
early emphasis on administrative and training functions to
what amounts to a combat role as an internal security force
in Iraq. He cites company representatives who say
Blackwater's capacities can readily be expanded to supplying
brigade-sized forces for humanitarian purposes, peacekeeping
and low-level conflict. While emphasizing the possibility of
an "adventurous President" employing Blackwater's
mercenaries covertly, Scahill underestimates the effect of
publicity on the deniability he sees as central to such
scenarios. Arguably, he also dismisses too lightly
Blackwater's growing self-image as the respectable heir to a
long and honorable tradition of contract soldiering.
Ultimately, Blackwater and its less familiar counterparts
thrive not because of a neoconservative conspiracy against
democracy, as Scahill claims, but because they provide
relatively low-cost alternatives in high-budget environments
and flexibility at a time when war is increasingly protean.
Review. Amazon / Reed Business Information, a division of
Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
pdxjustice.org
Jeremy Scahill talks about Blackwater
(2008)
Schumacher, Gerald: A bloody Business, America's war
zone contractor and the occupation of Iraq, Zenith
Press, St. Paul, 2006, 304 p., ISBN: 0 7603 2355 0
Retired army colonel Schumacher polishes the public image
of private wartime contractors in this informative if
relentlessly glowing account of these "unrecognized and
unappreciated patriots" in Iraq and Kuwait. Schumacher
gained access to employees from contracting firms MPRI and
Crescent Security, and his perspective is one of deep
affection and respect—for people who put themselves in
harm's way to provide security for diplomats, to move
convoys of precious materials and to rebuild the broken
infrastructure of war-torn countries. Describing the
day-to-day operations of the trucking, training and security
contractors he interviewed in Kuwait and Iraq, Schumacher
argues that they don't work for the money (MPRI workers' pay
comes to under $20 an hour) but out of a sense of adventure,
patriotism and expertise. The author's voice is
unpretentious but swaggering, tough but sentimental; he's as
critical of the Bush administration for its ill-conceived
strategies as of the media for what he considers prejudice.
There's not much in the way of subtle policy debate or
comprehensive analysis ("Department of Defense outsourcing
to civilian contractors is an efficient, short-term
solution"), but Schumacher writes with a keen sense of
justice and empathy as he recounts the harrowing tales of
these contractors-for-hire. Review. Amazon / Publishers
Weekly / Reed Business Information, a division of Reed
Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Singer, Peter, W.: The Rise of the privatized military
industry, Cornell University Press, Ithaca and London,
2003, 326 p., ISBN: 0-8014-8915-6
Some have claimed that "War is too important to be left
to the generals", but P.W. Singer asks "What about the
business executives?". Breaking out of the guns-for-hire
mould of traditional mercenaries, corporations now sell
skills and services that until recently only state
militaries possessed. Their products range from trained
commando teams to strategic advice from generals. This new
"privatized military industry" encompasses hundreds of
companies, thousands of employees, and billions in revenue.
Whether as proxies or suppliers, such firms have
participated in wars in Africa, Asia, the Balkans and Latin
America. More recently, they have become a key element in US
military operations. Private corporations working for profit
now sway the course of national and international conflict,
but the consequences have been little explored. In this
book, Singer provides an account of the military services
industry and its broader implications. "Corporate Warriors"
includes a description of how the business works, as well as
portraits of each of the basic types of companies: military
providers that offer troops for tactical operations;
military consultants that supply expert advice and training;
and military support companies that sell logistics,
intelligence and engineering. The privatization of warfare
allows startling new capabilities and efficiencies in the
ways that war is carried out. At the same time, however,
Singer finds that the entrance of the profit motive onto the
battlefield raises a series of troubling questions - for
democracy, for ethics, for management, for human rights and
for national security. A security analyst at the Brookings
Institution, Singer raises disturbing new issues in this
comprehensive analysis of a post-Cold War phenomenon:
private companies offering specialized military services for
hire. These organizations are nothing like the mercenary
formations that flourished in post-independence Africa,
whose behavior there earned them the nickname les affreux:
"the frightful ones." Today's corporate war-making agencies
are bought and sold by Fortune 500 firms. Even some UN
peacekeeping experts, Singer reports, advocate their use on
grounds of economy and efficiency. Governments see in them a
means of saving money-and sometimes a way to use low-profile
force to solve awkward, potentially embarrassing situations
that develop on the fringes of policy. Singer describes
three categories of privatized military systems. "Provider
firms" (the best known being the now reorganized Executive
Outcomes) offer direct, tactical military assistance ranging
from training programs and staff services to front-line
combat. "Consulting firms," like the U.S.-based Military
Professional Resources Inc., draw primarily on retired
senior officers to provide strategic and administrative
expertise on a contract basis. The ties of such groups to
their country of origin, Singer finds, can be expected to
weaken as markets become more cosmopolitan. Finally, the
overlooked "support firms," like Brown & Root, provide
logistic and maintenance services to armed forces preferring
(or constrained by budgetary factors) to concentrate their
own energies on combat. Singer takes pains to establish the
improvements in capability and effectiveness privatization
allows, ranging from saving money to reducing human
suffering by ending small-scale conflicts. He is, however,
far more concerned with privatization's negative
implications. Technical issues, like contract problems, may
lead to an operation ending without regard to a military
rationale. A much bigger problem is the risk of states
losing control of military policy to militaries outside the
state systems, responsible only to their clients, managers,
and stockholders, Singer emphasizes. So far, private
military organizations have behaved cautiously, but there is
no guarantee will continue. Nor can the moralities of
business firms be necessarily expected to accommodate such
niceties as the laws of war. Singer recommends increased
oversight as a first step in regulation, an eminently
reasonable response to a still imperfectly understood
development in war making. Review. Amazon / Publishers
Weekly / Reed Business Information, a division of Reed
Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.
Big Think
Peter W. Singer on Holding Private Military Companies
Accountable
(2012)
Venter, Al: War Dog: Fighting other people's wars, The
modern mercenary in combat, Casemate Publishers and book
Distributors LLC, 2005, 609 p., ISBN: 1932033092
Mercenaries have been around since the dawn of
civilization, yet today they are little understood. While
many modern freelance fighters provide support for larger
military establishments, others wage war where the great
powers refuse. In War Dog, Al Venter examines the latter, in
the process he unveils a remarkable array of close-quarters
combat action. Having personally visited everywhere he
describes, Venter is the rare correspondent who had to carry
an AK-47 in his research along with his notebook and camera.
To him, covering mercenary actions meant accompanying the
men into the thick of combat. During Sierra Leone's civil
war, he flew in the government's lone Hind gun ship-piloted
by the heroic chopper ace "Nellis"-as it flew daily missions
to blast apart rebel positions. In this book Venter
describes the battles of the South African mercenary company
Executive Outcomes and after stemming the tide of Jonas
Savimbi's UNITA army in Angola they headed north to hold
back vicious rebels in West Africa. This book is not only
about triumph against adversity but also losses, as Venter
relates the death and subsequent cannibalistic fate of his
American friend, Bob MacKenzie, in Sierra Leone. Here we see
the plight of thousands of civilians fleeing from homicidal
jungle warriors, as well as the professionalism of the
mercenaries who fought back with one hand and attempted to
train government troops with the other. The American public,
as well as its military, largely sidestepped the horrific
conflicts that embroiled Africa during the past two decades.
But as Venter informs us, there were indeed small numbers of
professional fighters on the ground, defending civilians and
attempting to conjure order from chaos. In this book we gain
an intimate glimpse of this modern breed of warrior in
combat. Not laden with medals, or even guaranteed income,
they have fought some of the toughest battles in the post-
Cold War era. They simply are, and perhaps always will be,
"War Dogs." Review. Amazon.
Young Pelton, Robert: Licenced to kill, the
Privatisation of the war on terror, Crown Publishers,
2006, 288 p., ISBN: 1400097819
Robert Young Pelton first became aware of the phenomenon
of hired guns in the War on Terror when he met a covert team
of contractors on the Afghanistan/Pakistan border in the
fall of 2003. Pelton soon embarked on a globe-spanning
odyssey to penetrate and understand this shadowy world,
ultimately delivering stunning insights into the way private
soldiers are used. Enter a blood-soaked world of South
African mercenaries and tribal fighters backed by ruthless
financiers. Drop into Baghdad’s Green Zone, strap on body
armor, and take a daily high-speed ride with a doomed crew
of security contractors who dodge car bombs and snipers just
to get their charges to the airport. Share a drink in a chic
hotel bar with wealthy owners of private armies who debate
the best way to stay alive in war zones. Licensed to Kill
spans four continents and three years, taking us inside the
CIA’s dirty wars; the brutal contractor murders in Fallujah
and the Alamo-like sieges in Najaf and Al Kut; the Deep
South contractor training camps where ex–Special Operations
soldiers and even small town cops learn the ropes; the
contractor conventions where macho attendees swap
bullet-punctuated tales and discuss upcoming gigs; and the
grim Central African prison where contractors turned failed
mercenaries pay a steep price. The United States has
encouraged the use of the private sector in all facets of
the War on Terror, placing contractors outside the bounds of
functional legal constraints. With the shocking clarity that
can come only from firsthand observation, Licensed to
Kill painstakingly deconstructs the most controversial
events and introduces the pivotal players. Most
disturbingly, it shows that there are indeed thousands of
contractors—with hundreds more being produced every
month—who’ve been given a license to kill, their services
available to the highest bidder. Review: Amazon /
Backcover.
IN GERMAN
Azzellini, Dario; Kanzleiter, Boris: Das Unternehmen
Krieg, Paramilitärs, Warlords und Privatarmeen als Akteure
der Neuen Kriegsordnung, Assoziation A, 2003, 215 p.,
ISBN: 3935936176
Dass eine neue Weltordnung auch eine neue Kriegsordnung
impliziere, darauf wird emblematisch bereits im Untertitel
des Sammelbands hingewiesen. Das bedeutet nun aber nicht,
dass die Autoren die neuen Kriege, die ja zuallererst
singuläre Erscheinungen sind, bloß über einen
historisch-materialistisch aktualisierten
Interpretationskamm scheren würden. Vielmehr wird
unterschiedlichsten Vorort-Verhältnissen in Fallstudien
nachgegangen und dabei auch überwiegend auf unabhängige und
einheimische Informationen zurückgegriffen. Vorangeschickt
ist zwar ein die politisch-theoretische Ausrichtung
klärender Aufsatz, dem dann aber Untersuchungen zu Kolumbien,
der Türkei, Mexiko, Guatemala, dem ehemaligen Jugoslawien,
Afghanistan, Indonesien, dem Kongo und Angola folgen. Die
hier versammelten Untersuchungen zeigen an Beispielen
buchstäblich aus aller Welt, dass die Trennung zwischen
staatlicher und privater Gewaltausübung, zwischen
militärischen und ökonomischen Interessen, zwischen
organisierter Kriminalität und dem Weltmarkt, zwischen 1.
und 3. Welt und zu guter Letzt und ganz zentral eben die
Unterscheidung zwischen Krieg und Normalzustand immer
poröser wird. Review : Amazon / Deutschlandfunk.
>>>FREE
DOWNLOAD OF THE BOOK PROVIDED BY THE AUTOR (In German)
Uesseler, Rolf: Krieg als Dienstleistung,
Private Militärfirmen zerstören die Demokratie, Ch.
Links Verlag, 2006, 240 p., ISBN: 3 86153 385 5
"Private Militärfirmen verdienen nicht am Frieden,
sondern am Krieg und Konflikten." (Rolf Uesseler) Das
Eingangszitat und der Untertitel "Private Militärfirmen
zerstören die Demokratie" unterstreichen die Zielrichtung
des kritischen Sachbuches, das im März 2008 bereits in
seiner aktualisierten, um das Kapitel "Blackwater"
erweiterten, 3. Auflage erschienen ist. Der freie Publizist
und Wissenschaftler bringt hierbei seine Erfahrungen ein,
die er schon zuvor im Zusammenhang mit den Themenfeldern
Illegale Trends der Weltwirtschaft, Organisierte
Kriminalität und Schattenökonomie gemacht hat. Mit dem Ende
des Ost-West-Konflikts und dem Fall des Eisernen Vorhangs
wurde der Weltmarkt mit Waffen geradezu überschwemmt. Von
der Öffentlichkeit weitgehend unbemerkt sind seit über einem
Jahrzehnt Private Militärfirmen (PMF) in aller Welt tätig.
Neben einem Merkblatt für die Anwerbung eines Privatsoldaten
(Seite 13) schildert der Autor einige typische
Söldnerkarrieren. Ihre Existenz wurde kaum wahrgenommen und
nur selten thematisiert. Es bedurfte erst einiger Skandale
und des Irak-Krieges, damit die Öffentlichkeit auf dieses
Phänomen aufmerksam wurde. So stand beipielsweise hinter dem
Folterskandal im Gefängnis von Abu Ghraib mit Steve
Stefanowicz ein Verhörspezialist der privaten PMF "CACI
International" mit Sitz in Arlington/Virginia (S. 34). Oder
wenn es z. B. Hackern gelungen war, in das Sicherheitssystem
des US-Präsidenten einzudringen. So wurde bekannt, dass die
Hälfte des 40 Milliarden Dollar Budgets für die
verschiedenen US-Geheimdienste mittlerweile an verschiedene
PMF gezahlt wird. Im Bereich Logistik haben die PMF in den
angelsächsischen Ländern nahezu eine Monopolstellung erlangt.
Während der Branchenumsatz im Jahr 2005 bei ca. 200
Milliarden Euro lag, findet man die umsatzstärksten Firmen
mit ihren Stammhäusern unter den ersten 100 der am höchsten
notierten Aktiengesellschaften der jeweiligen Länder. Ganz
klar, denn PMF gehorchen ausschließlich den Marktregeln, das
heißt dem Gesetz von Angebot und Nachfrage. Sie verfahren
nicht anders als anderen privaten Wirtschaftsbetrieben. Die
wahrgenommenen Aufgaben, die auch als Dienstleistungspakete
angeboten werden gliedern sich in die Bereiche Sicherheit,
Ausbildung, Intelligence und Logistik. Ihre Dienstleistungen
sind jedoch als schnelle und effiziente Lösungen,
langfristig gesehen gewissermaßen Wegwerfprodukte. Einmal
benutzt sind sie auch verbraucht. Mit "Write a cheque and
end a war" , à la Präsident der IPOA, Doug Brooks, ist es
nicht weit her... Der Autor liefert eine scharfe und
gründliche Analyse der Gefahren, die sich aus dem Engagement
der PMF ergeben. Hierzu gibt er nicht nur abstrakte
Beispiele, sondern nennt stets Ross und Reiter. Er
unterscheidet zwischen sogenannten "starken" Staaten, deren
transnationalen Konzerne in einer Verteidigungsschlacht um
die ökonomischen Ressourcen der "schwachen, verfallenden"
Staaten kämpfen. Die Grenzen zwischen wirtschaftlichem,
politischen und humanitärem Gründen in der Zusammenarbeit
mit Wirtschaftsunternehmen, Staaten, Regierungen, Hilfs- und
Friedensorganisation, sogar die UNU wird durch die PMF nicht
nur verwischt. Bei einigen Ländern ist kaum noch
festzustellen, wo das nationale Interesse aufhört und das
Konzerninteresse anfängt. Mit Blick auf die angelsächsischen
Länder muss gar der Eindruck entstehen, dass von diesen nur
dort militärisch interveniert wird, wo "etwas zu holen" ist.
So wurde die neue nationale Energiepolitik Georges W. Bush
ungewollt oder gewollt mit dem globalen "Krieg gegen den
Terror" verwoben. Eine Verflechtung zwischen staatlichen und
privaten Akteure ist vornehmlich in den USA zu finden.
Während sich auch Defensiv- und Offensivcharakter verwischen
können, kann eine ursprünglich von politischer Ethik
getragene Friedensmissionen fraglich werden. Uesseler gibt
zahlreiche Beispiele für Macht und Möglichkeiten der PMF.
Während die Gesamte US-Mission im Kosovo und ihr Gelingen
von den Kapazitäten der Firma KBR abhing, verfügt "Executive
Outcomes" (EO) über eine komplette Armee mit einem
Stammpersonal von 2000 hochspezialisierten Soldaten,
Schützen- und Transportpanzern, sieben Kampfhubschrauber und
acht Flugzeugen der Typen MiG 23, MiG 27 und SU 25. (Das
ganze Firmenimperium wird in einer Übersicht auf Seite 80
dargestellt.) Das vom Ex-Navy Seal Eric Prince 1997
Blackwater Worlwide rekrutiert Privatsoldaten vornehmlich
aus Ländern der 3. Welt. Neben Philippinos zählen hierzu
auch Spezialisten aus der ehemaligen Junta Pinochets.
Nachdem am 16. September 2007 am Nisour Platz in Bagdad 17
irakische Zivilisten von einem Blackwater-Spezialisten
grundlos erschossen worden waren, konnte der diplomatische
Konflikt konnte nur durch das persönliche Eingreifen von US-Außenministerin
Rice beigelegt werden. Insgesamt gab es 63 Vorfälle bei
denen Blackwater-Mitarbeiter als zuerst schossen.
Angestellte, die durch den Abschluss verbindlicher Verträge
mit völkerrechtlich anerkannten Regierungen gegenüber der
Justiz abgesichert sind, unterliegen keiner staatlichen
Kontrolle und erzeugen daher so gut wie keine "Overhead-Kosten".
Dennoch ist die Behauptung, dass ein Outsourcing für den
Auftragsstaat Staat billiger sei ein gravierender Irrtum!
Während für einen Sergeant 140 - 190 Dollar pro Tag zu
veranschlagen sind, Ein kostet ein neuer ca.1222 Dollar.
Daneben liegen Exportproduktionszonen der sog. Maquiladora
Industrien in nahezu exterritorialen Produktionszonen. In
diesen rechtsfreien Räumen sind nicht nur Lohndumping keine
Grenzen gesetzt. Verbrecher kommen straffrei davon. Als
Beispiele dienen Kolumbien (S. 139) und afrikanische Staaten
(S. 166), wo es auch zu Straftaten und
Menschenrechtsverletzungen gegen Arbeiter und Gewerkschafter
kam. Ab Seite 89 gibt es einen Abriss über "Die Geschichte
der Kriegswirtschaft", die beim biblischen David beginnt und
über Hopliten der griechischen Poleis, den Seldschuken und
Condottieri, den Landsknechten und Schweizer Garden der
Ostindischen Kompanie und an England verkaufte Hessische
Untertanen bis zum Eisernen Kreuz Träger Siegfried "Kongo"
Müller reicht. Die Warnung vor dem beschleunigten Niedergang
des Nationalstaates, einer Erosion des Gewaltmonopols, der
schwindenden Souveränität und die allmähliche Auflösung des
Staates dargelegt. Als eklatantes Beispiel nennt er die
Privatisierung von Gefängnissen. (S. 195) Glücklicherweise
gab es bereits Reaktionen in der Politik. Im Herbst 2004
brachte die CDU/CSU Fraktion einen Antrag in den Bundestag
ein, in dem es hieß, dass die Privatisierung langfristig zu
einem fundamentalen Wandel zwischen Militär und
Nationalstaat führen kann. Über alle Parteigrenzen hinweg
war man sich einig, dass Militärfirmen zu einem Staat im
Staate werden und dessen Existenz gefährden können Das EU-Parlament
griff die mangelnde Kontrolle und Verantwortlichkeit auf,
indem es eine Entschließung verabschiedete, die eine
Finanzierung von Todesschwadronen durch die British Patrol
scharf verurteilte. UNO beauftragte einen "Sonderberichterstatter
für das Söldnerwesen",denn das Völkerrecht kennt für den
Kriegsfall nur Kombattanten und Zivilbevölkerung. Die neuen
Söldner sind jedoch weder das Eine noch das Andere. In
seinen Schlussbemerkungen stellt der Autor einen
Forderungskatalog für das Engagement deutscher Firmen auf.
17 Seiten Anmerkungen (Fussnoten & Quellen) und ein Pro und
Contra PMF für die Bereiche Wirtschaftlichkeit, Militär,
Peacekeeping und humanitäre Einsätze, Internationale Krisen,
Technologie, Politik und Recht sind abschließende Belege
dafür, dass sich Uesseler durchaus differenziert mit der
Thematik auseinander gesetzt hat. Das Buch ist zuerst
sicherlich keine Lektüre für militärische Abenteurer,
Hightechwaffen-Freaks, die gerne Einsatzberichte und
technische Details wissen wollen oder Lobbyisten der Branche.
Sie dennoch auf ihre Kosten, den im Anhang gibt es neben
einem fünfseitigen Verzeichnis weiterführender Literatur
auch eine alphabetische Auflistung der wichtigsten PMF im
Internet mit deren Firmensitz und Arbeitsschwerpunkten. Den
Abschluss bildet ein Personen- und Firmenregister. Review
Amazon / Timediver – Ronald Funck.
Wulf, Herbert: Internationalisierung und
Privatisierung von Krieg und Frieden, Nomos Verlag,
2005, 258 p., ISBN: 3-8329-1375-0
»Die Welt ist wohl nicht bereit, den Frieden zu
privatisieren«, sagte Kofi Annan 1996 als sich in Ruanda
abermals ein Flüchtlingsdrama anbahnte. Der UN
Sicherheitsrat konnte sich weder dazu entschließen
Friedenstruppen zu entsenden, noch das Angebot einer
privaten Militärfirma anzunehmen, die binnen sechs Wochen
ein Kontingent von 1500 Firmensoldaten zum Schutz der
Flüchtlinge einsetzen wollte. Für die Privatisierung des
Krieges scheint die Welt aber reif zu sein. Heute kommt auf
8 US-Soldaten im Irak mindestens 1 Angestellter einer
Militärfirma, die Militär- und Polizeiaufgaben wahrnehmen.
Immer häufiger verlässt sich das Militär auf diese neuen
privaten Militärdienstleister. Internationale militärische
Interventionen und die Privatisierung des Militärs stehen im
Mittelpunkt der Veröffentlichung. Anhand verschiedener
Fallstudien (UN-Friedensmissionen, Krisenreaktionskräfte der
EU, Peacekeeping Südafrikas, Konkurrenz und Kooperation
zwischen Militär und Hilfsorganisationen in
Nachkriegswiederaufbauprogrammen, Privatisierung des
Militärs in Großbritannien und USA, militärische Einsätze
gegen Terroristen) zeigt der Autor zwei problematische
Tendenzen auf: die Internationalisierung und die
Privatisierung des Militärs und deren negative Auswirkungen
für die Aufrechterhaltung des staatlichen Gewaltmonopols.
Review : Verlagsinformation.
IN FRENCH
Cécile, Jean-Jacques: Chiens de Guerre de l’Amérique,
Nouveau Monde Éditions, 2008, 298 p., ISBN:
978-2-84736-372-2
16 septembre 2007. Dans le square Nisour, à Bagdad, des
hommes de la société militaire privée Blackwater dégainent
leur arme et tirent. Bilan: 17 morts, 24 blessés. Des civils.
Face au carnage, le Premier ministre irakien, Nouri al-Maliki,
exige le bannissement de l'entreprise. Demande bien inutile,
pense ce diplomate américain qui affirme: "Nous révoquerons
la licence d'al-Maliki avant qu'il ne révoque celle de
Blackwater." Ces sociétés sont de vrais empires, économiques,
avec des milliers d'employés, des chiffres d'affaires
astronomiques, le tout bâti en quelques années, par la grâce
de liens étroits et nébuleux avec les responsables de
l'administration Bush. Si ces entreprises sont apparues dans
les années 1970, recrutant anciens des forces spéciales et
des services action, leur nombre ne cesse de se multiplier
depuis une dizaine d'années. Voici pour la première fois en
France une enquête sans concession sur leurs ramifications,
leurs pratiques et leurs dangers. Review: Amazon.
Hier chasse gardée des Etats, le renseignement est
aujourd'hui une marchandise comme une autre. Tendance lourde
des sociétés démocratiques et libérales et venue du monde
anglosaxon, la privatisation de l'espionnage a pour effet de
radicaliser les pratiques politiques, économiques et
médiatiques. Dans ce nouveau marché privé mais peuplé de
talents formés dans les organismes étatiques, le client paie
pour connaître en profondeur son adversaire, le déstabiliser
et même le salir : tous les coups sont permis. La France
elle-même est prise dans le phénomène. A-t-elle le choix
quand ses entreprises subissent une déstabilisation
croissante venue d'Outre-Atlantique ? Preuves et exemples à
l'appui, Jean-Jacques Cécile démonte ici les rouages de la
collusion croissante entre gouvernements, services secrets
et sociétés commerciales au mépris de toute déontologie,
jusqu'à inquiéter le lecteur quant à l'évolution des
démocraties. Review: Amazon.
Chapleau, Philippe: Les mercenaires de l’Antiquité à
nos jours, Edition Ouest-France, 2006, 127 p., ISBN: 2
7373 3778 X
Le mercenariat n'est pas moribond. L'extinction des "
Affreux ", ces mercenaires à la réputation sulfureuse des
années de la décolonisation, n'a constitué qu'une étape dans
une histoire séculaire. Depuis l'époque des pharaons
égyptiens, des hommes de guerre ont monnayé leur expérience
militaire et ont combattu pour des rois, des cités ou des
Etats qui n'étaient pas les leurs. Aujourd'hui, alors que la
privatisation de la défense s'accélère, les mercenaires
travaillent pour des sociétés militaires privées. Soldats
sans armée, ils sont présents sur les champs de bataille
d'Afrique, du Moyen-Orient et d'Amérique latine. Ils gèrent
des bases militaires, assurent la logistique des unités en
opérations extérieures, entraînent les forces spéciales et
les pilotes de nombreuses armées... Ils assurent aussi la
protection des ONG et des missions diplomatiques. Peut-être
serviront-ils bientôt les Nations unies sous le casque bleu
? A l'heure d'une inquiétante abdication régalienne et où
tout, même la sécurité, devient une marchandise, l'avenir du
mercenariat n'a jamais semblé aussi prometteur. Déjà auteur
de deux ouvrages sur le mercenariat et la privatisation de
la guerre, Philippe Chapleau retrace ici l'histoire des
guerriers antiques, des condottieri, des corsaires, des
soldats de fortune, des " chiens de guerre " et des
volontaires étrangers..., qui ont fait commerce de leurs
armes et de leurs compétences militaires au cours des trente
derniers siècles. Review: Amazon.
Chapleau, Philippe: Société Militaire Privées,
Edition du Rocher, 2005, 305 p., ISBN: 2268054292
Le monde est entré dans une ère où la force militaire a
cessé d'être la prérogative exclusive des armées nationales.
Désormais, des sociétés militaires privées jouent un rôle
essentiel, voire légitime, dans les domaines de la défense
et de la politique étrangère. Des Etats cèdent même à la
tentation d'opérations militaires livrées clefs en main par
des entrepreneurs de guerre. Les hommes et les femmes qui
travaillent pour ces prestataires de services militaires ne
ressemblent guère aux mercenaires individuels de l'après
Seconde Guerre mondiale. Les guerriers privés de ce début du
XXIe siècle ne sont plus seulement d'anciens soldats des
unités d'élite. Ils sont aussi pilotes d'hélicoptères,
instructeurs, logisticiens, informaticiens, analystes. Leurs
employeurs ont pignon sur rue. Les entreprises de ces
condottieri modernes sont cotées en bourse ; leurs sites
Internet vantent la qualité de leurs services et le large
éventail de leurs prestations (formation, conseil,
logistique, protection, renseignement, communications,
soutien tactique). Parmi leurs clients, des ministères de la
Défense, de l'Intérieur et des Affaires étrangères, des
forces de police, des collectivités, des multinationales,
des gouvernements étrangers décidés, eux aussi, à privatiser
une partie de leurs pouvoirs régaliens. Ce livre est une
enquête sur la stratégie de délégation adoptée par de
nombreux États et sur les entreprises, principalement
anglo-saxonnes, qui ont repris à leur compte des missions
traditionnellement effectuées par les armées nationales et
désormais confiées aux soldats sans armées des sociétés
militaires privées. La collection L'Art de la Guerre publie
les textes essentiels des cultures stratégiques de tous les
continents. Review: Amazon.
Hubac, Olivier: Mercenaires et polices privées – La
privatisation de la violence armée, Universalis, 2005,
192 p., ISBN: 2-85229-790-6
Deuxième force d'occupation armée en Irak, les
mercenaires sont désormais organisés en véritables sociétés
militaires privées. Sur fond de réduction des budgets
militaires, d'une technicisation de la guerre et de
l'émergence de la doctrine du " zéro mort ", les successeurs
de Bob Denard exploitent désormais un véritable marché qui,
avec celui de la sécurité privée, pèse plus de 100 milliards
de dollars par an. L'activité croissante de ces sociétés
remet en cause le monopole de la violence légitime exercée
par les Etats. Doit-on y voir une nouvelle privatisation ou
bien la mise en place d'une délégation de service public ?
Ce livre confronte, sur le plan du droit comme sur le plan
des pratiques, les modèles anglo-saxon et français, sur
trois terrains d'observation : les interventions militaires,
les opérations de police et la gestion des centres
pénitentiaires. Review: Amazon.
Renou, Xavier: La privatisation de la violence?,
Mercenaire et sociétés militaires privées au service du
marché, Agone, 2005, 488 p., ISBN:
2-7489-0059-62717849920
La marchandisation s'étend désormais au domaine de la "
violence légitime ", un secteur en plein essor qui
représenterait déjà un bénéfice annuel de plus de 100
milliards de dollars. Les mercenaires de jadis sont
aujourd'hui les employés de " sociétés militaires privées "
parfaitement légales qui, renvoyant à un passé révolu
l'image sulfureuse des " chiens de guerre ", tentent de se
construire un rôle respectable dans la fiction d'un marché
dispensateur de paix et de démocratie. Elles proposent
pourtant à leurs clients (États, firmes multinationales,
mouvements armés divers) les habituelles prestations d'ordre
militaire : opérations de déstabilisation, combat, conseil
en stratégie, logistique, etc. C'est ainsi, par exemple,
qu'une firme dont la mission officielle de " formation à la
transition démocratique" conduit au bombardement de civils
recevra la bénédiction aussi bien de son client que des
instances de contrôle. Parce qu'elles font pleinement jouer
le mécanisme de circulation entre les secteurs militaires
privé et public - l'une d'elles a recruté successivement
l'ancien secrétaire à la Défense de Ronald Reagan, l'ancien
secrétaire d'État lames Baker et l'ancien président des
États-Unis George Bush père -, les sociétés mercenaires
influent de plus en plus sur les politiques de " défense ".
Parce qu'elles se mettent au service des multinationales qui
exploitent les pays du Sud dotés en ressources minières, ces
sociétés agissent comme les gardiens d'un ordre économique
qui maintient dans la plus grande dépendance des pays en
principe libérés depuis plusieurs décennies du joug
colonial. Les sociétés militaires privées seraient-elles
l'instrument privilégié du retour de l'impérialisme ?
Review: Amazon.
Roche, Jean-Jacques: Insécurités publiques, sécurité
privée?, Essais sur les nouveaux mercenaires,
Economica, 2005, 420 p., ISBN-10: 2717849920
La privatisation de la sécurité signifie-t-elle le retour
des Grandes Compagnies, aussi peu fiables sur le champ de
bataille que dangereuses en dehors ? Au-delà des craintes
légitimes que suscite cette évolution, le présent ouvrage
analyse la privatisation de la sécurité à la fois comme la
conséquence de la professionnalisation des armées et comme
la résultante de la transformation des conflits. Review:
Economica.